Trailmark Homes For Sale, St. Johns County

Trailmark is a nature- and lake-oriented master-planned new-construction community in St. Johns County, set near St. Augustine along the CR-210 corridor. As its name suggests, the community leans into the outdoors, and its homes reflect a more mid-market profile than some of its larger neighbors: prices run from the mid $300s to around $1.2 million, with a median near $465,000. Every home here is a single-family residence, ranging from about 1,579 to 4,047 square feet with 2 to 6 bedrooms. Many listings feature a screened lanai, flexible bonus or flex space, a pool, and access to community amenities — details that suit both growing families and buyers who want room to spread out. Trailmark also carries a notable active-adult (55+) presence, making it worth a look for downsizers.

Because these are new-construction homes, keep in mind that the builder's model-home agent works for the builder. Having your own REALTOR — whose commission the builder typically pays — means someone is representing your side through pricing, inspections, and closing. Krista Fracke, a Broker Associate with Christie's International Real Estate First Coast, can tour Trailmark with you and compare it candidly to nearby options.

Students here are served by the St. Johns County School District — consistently ranked Florida's #1 public district — including Picolata Crossing Elementary, Pacetti Bay Middle, and Tocoi Creek High School. With nearly all homes in low-risk flood zones and easy reach to St. Augustine, Trailmark blends an outdoor lifestyle with practical everyday access.

Trailmark is the more mid-market and outdoor-focused of the two communities. Its median sits around $465,000, and every home is a single-family residence with a nature- and trail-oriented character — no townhomes. SilverLeaf, by contrast, spans a wider and higher price range (from the low $300s up to roughly $1.5 million, median near $609,000), includes both single-family homes and townhomes within a gated setting, and reaches larger floor plans. Notably, Trailmark carries a larger active-adult (55+) share than SilverLeaf, though both offer 55+ homes. The two communities share Tocoi Creek High School and Pacetti Bay Middle, and both sit almost entirely in low-risk FEMA Zone X near St. Augustine. Choose Trailmark for a single-family, outdoor lifestyle; choose SilverLeaf for broader price range and townhome options.