Indian Trace Homes For Sale, St. Augustine

Indian Trace sits in a quiet, rural pocket of St. Augustine where the surrounding landscape tends to favor space and privacy over walkable amenities — and for buyers who want that, it delivers. Dinner out often means a drive to Cap's on the Water, the beloved waterfront seafood spot on the Intracoastal Waterway roughly 14 miles away. Anastasia State Park, with its wide Atlantic beach, dune trails, and kayak launch, is about 15 miles from the community, and the Guana Tolomato Matanzas Research Reserve — 76,000 acres of protected coastal wilderness — is about 16 miles north. For shopping, St. Augustine Premium Outlets is only about 6 miles away, making it the easiest errand run in the area.

Homes in Indian Trace are single-family, with ranch and traditional styles being the most common architectural expressions. Living areas typically run from about 3,300 to nearly 3,900 square feet, and floor plans lean toward four to six bedrooms with three-and-a-half to five bathrooms — spacious, open layouts designed for comfortable day-to-day living on large land parcels. Every home that has come to market here has had a private pool. Interiors commonly feature vaulted or soaring ceilings, open floorplans, kitchen islands with breakfast bars and nooks, walk-in and his-and-hers closets, and primary suites on the main level — details that reflect the custom or semi-custom caliber of construction from the 1990s and 2000s. Prices have ranged from the mid-$800s up to about $2.9 million, with the upper end reflecting equestrian-capable estates on 19 or more high-and-dry acres.

Indian Trace is positioned in a rural stretch of St. Augustine in St. Johns County, west of the coastal communities and closer to the inland corridor along I-95. Flagler Health+ Village at St. Augustine, the region's primary hospital with full emergency and surgical services, is about 12 miles away. Baptist Medical Center South is roughly 20 miles, and Mayo Clinic Florida's campus is about 24 miles. Jacksonville International Airport is approximately 42 miles north — plan on roughly 45 minutes to an hour depending on traffic. Vilano Beach is the closest beach access at about 14 miles, with St. Augustine Beach about 16 miles. The St. Johns County School District website has an address-specific school locator for confirming zone assignments.

Indian Trace is zoned for Picolata Crossing Elementary, Pacetti Bay Middle, and Tocoi Creek High School, all part of the St. Johns County School District. School assignments are address-specific — always verify with the district's official school locator before relying on any zoning information.