Surfside Homes For Sale, St. Augustine

Daily life in Surfside is shaped by its coastal setting: Vilano Beach is about a five-minute walk, and Cap's on the Water — an iconic waterfront seafood restaurant on the Intracoastal Waterway — is about 4 miles away. The St. Augustine Historic District, with its cobblestone streets, galleries, and restaurants, is roughly 2 miles from the neighborhood, and the St. Augustine Amphitheatre, which hosts national touring acts in an intimate outdoor setting, is within about 3 miles. Anastasia State Park, a 1,600-acre coastal park with wide beach, dune trails, and a kayak launch, is about 4 miles south — and the 76,000-acre Guana Tolomato Matanzas Research Reserve for birding, hiking, and protected coastal wilderness is roughly 12 miles north. What surprises people when they first look at Surfside is how much history, nature, and water access you get within such a short radius.

Homes in Surfside tend toward cottage and traditional styles, reflecting the neighborhood's relaxed coastal character. Recent listings have ranged from roughly 750 to about 4,000 square feet, with 2 to 4 bedrooms, and prices spanning from the upper $800s into the mid $1 millions. The inventory here is a genuine mix — you'll find vintage cottages built as early as the 1920s alongside newly constructed coastal residences, and even some vacant lots where buyers can work with a builder to design a custom home from the ground up. Inside, common features include open floorplans, kitchen islands, and pantries — details that reflect the shift toward modern coastal living even in smaller footprints.

Surfside sits in the Vilano Beach corridor just north of the St. Augustine Historic District, with Vilano Beach about a quarter mile to the east. Flagler Health+ Village at St. Augustine — the primary regional hospital for St. Johns County — is about 3 miles away. St. Augustine Premium Outlets are roughly 8 miles northwest, and the Pavilion at Durbin Park is about 15 miles north along I-95. Jacksonville International Airport is approximately 46 miles north, a drive that typically runs under an hour in light traffic.

Specific school assignments for Surfside addresses are handled through the St. Johns County School District, which serves this area. Because school zoning is address-specific, I always recommend verifying the exact schools for any property you're seriously considering through the district's official school locator.