St. Augustine Beach & Anastasia Island
Homes for Sale in St. Augustine Beach & Anastasia Island
230 homes · 9 new this week · updated 18 minutes ago
St. Augustine Beach and Anastasia Island sit on the barrier island just east of historic downtown St. Augustine, framed by the Atlantic on one side and the Matanzas River on the other. The island is anchored by Anastasia State Park — roughly 1,600 acres of beach, dunes, marsh, and trails — with four miles of shoreline where cars stay off the sand, while sections of St. Augustine Beach to the south allow driving in designated areas. Housing runs the full range, from older beach cottages and walk-to-the-water bungalows to oceanfront and riverside condos and newer single-family homes, plus pockets like Butler Beach and Crescent Beach farther south.
Market Snapshot
As of September 23, 2026, the median list price in homes is $599,900 across 230 active listings, averaging $435/sqft; recent MLS-recorded sales show a median sold price of $558,000 across 139 closings.
- Median List Price
- $599,900
- Avg. Price / Sq Ft
- $435/sqft
- Median Sold (12 mo, MLS)
- $558,000
- ▼ 24.6% vs prior 6 mo
- Active Listings
- 230
- HOA Dues
- ~$509/mo typical
- 146 of 230 listings carry dues
What’s for sale: 222 homes (median $595,000) · 8 multi-family (median $784,500)
Market stats are based on similar homes in homes, including 139 recent recorded sales — they may not include listings or sales that aren't comparable to this market. Sourced from the MLS; refreshed regularly.
homes Home Values
The MLS-recorded sales above are what homes in homes actually sell for — and the comp set your future buyer will see. Own a home here? This page updates with every new listing, price change, and recorded sale, so following it is the simplest way to watch your equity. There’s no automated estimate on this site — when you want a real number, Krista prepares it personally against these sales.
Showing the 116 highest-priced matches — use the filters to narrow, or search the full map.
Showing 116 of 116
This market, from the inside
This area suits buyers who want beach access as part of everyday life — full-time residents, second-home owners, and anyone drawn to a walkable, low-rise coastal pace within reach of a working historic downtown. Because the island spans condos, cottages, and newer construction across zip 32080, use the filters to sort by price, type, and features like waterfront and pools — and reach out with questions about a specific street or building.
Frequently asked questions
What kinds of homes are on Anastasia Island?
A mix — older beach cottages, single-family homes, newer construction, and oceanfront and riverside condominiums. Options vary by location on the island, so filtering by property type, price, and features is the easiest way to see what fits.
How close is the island to historic St. Augustine?
Downtown St. Augustine is just across the bridge, putting the historic district, St. George Street, and the city’s shops and restaurants only a few minutes from most island neighborhoods.
Looking for homes?
I’ll send new listings the moment they hit the market and walk through the details that don’t show up in the MLS — water access, HOA rules, what a feature really costs to maintain.
Contact Krista