Skip to main content
Work directly with Krista on any home hereBroker Associate · 20+ years · 500+ closingsChristie's International Real Estate First Coast

Mill Creek Forest Homes For Sale, St. Johns

St. Johns, FL

7 homes · 1 new this week · median $551,999 · 33 sold in 12 mo at median $639,153 · 122 days avg on market · updated 5 minutes ago

Follow

New Mill Creek Forest homes the day they list · free, no account

Search freely — no forced sign-up, no call center, no data selling.

Why buyers stay

No account needed
Save homes the moment you find them — no sign-up wall.
The whole picture, up front
Flood risk, taxes, and true monthly cost on every listing.
Your data stays yours
No spam, not a call center — never sold to advertisers or data brokers.

Market Snapshot

As of October 28, 2026, recent MLS-recorded sales in Mill Creek Forest show a median sold price of $639,153 across 33 MLS-recorded sales; 7 homes are currently for sale ($499,900 - $894,000).

Median Sold (12 mo, MLS)
$639,153
▼ 0.7% vs prior 6 mo
Avg. Days to Sell
123 days
Homes Sold (12 mo)
33
For Sale Now
7
HOA Dues
~$153/mo typical

Market stats are based on similar homes in Mill Creek Forest, including 33 recent recorded sales — they may not include listings or sales that aren't comparable to this market. Sourced from the MLS; refreshed regularly.

Closed sales

What homes in Mill Creek Forest actually sold for

Median closed price by year from the MLS, 2024 to 2026: up 4% since 2025. 28 sales closed in 2026 at a median $238 per square foot.

$585K24$615K25$639K26$0$639K
YearSalesMedian sold$/sq ftOf askingDays on market
20246 †$585K$258100%123
202526$615K$23594.9%124
202628$639K$238100%106

Closed sales from the realMLS IDX feed; years with fewer than three sales are omitted. Medians, not estimates of any one home. "Of asking" is the median sold price as a share of the final list price. † A partial year in the feed: it carries only some of that year’s sales, so the median rests on fewer homes and the percent change above starts at the first full year.

Every Mill Creek Forest sale in the last 12 months, with prices →

Your beach from Mill Creek Forest

The closest public beach accesses with parking from Mill Creek Forest, by drive time where we have it, from the county and city beach-access maps.

Beach access near Julington Creek, mapped →Every public beach access and its parking, on one map →

Sea turtles nest on these beaches May 1 to October 31: the season’s rules. Looking for shark teeth? What you can keep, beach by beach. Dolphins and right whales: when and where to see them.

Public accesses only, from St. Johns County, City of Jacksonville Beach, City of Fernandina Beach and Florida DEP data. Parking counts are approximate, and fees, passes and seasonal rules change; check the posted signs.

Nature near Mill Creek Forest

The closest public trail systems and preserves (places with at least a mile of mapped trail or 500 acres), by drive time, from the state, water-district, county and National Park Service maps.

On the water

Fishing the First Coast →Every boat ramp →Every paddle launch →

Sports fields and leagues

  • Aberdeen Park

    11 min drive · Baseball, Football, Lacrosse, Softball, Track, Soccer

    Creeks Athletic Association; Creeks Flag Football; Field of Dreams Baseball; +1 more

  • Rivertown II Athletic Complex

    14 min drive · Soccer, Baseball, Basketball, Football, Pickleball, Softball

    Ancient City Soccer Club; Florida Prime Sports

  • Veterans Park

    15 min drive · Football, Soccer

    Creeks Flag Football; Sporting Jax Soccer Academy

Youth sports near Julington Creek, mapped →Every youth league in St. Johns and Duval, by sport →

Parks, trails and boat ramps near Julington Creek, mapped →Every state and national park within two hours →The springs, by drive time →

Public lands only; ramps and launches from FWC’s inventory, straight-line distance. Trail miles are what the managing agency maps; hours, fees, hunting seasons and closures change, so check the agency’s page before you go.

Groceries near Mill Creek Forest

The closest store of each big chain, by drive time, from the middle of Mill Creek Forest.

Grocery stores near Julington Creek, mapped →Every big-chain grocery store in St. Johns, Duval and Nassau →

Stores holding a state retail food permit, located from each chain’s own store list. Drive times are typical, without traffic.

The Neighborhood

About Mill Creek Forest, St. Johns

  • Community Type:
    Gated CommunityNew Construction AvailableMaster-Planned CommunityConservation / Nature Preserve
  • Property Type:
    Single Family Homes
  • Amenities:
    Community PoolTennis CourtsPickleball CourtsClubhouseFitness CenterWalking / Biking TrailsPlaygroundDog ParkBasketball Court

Touring model homes here? The on-site sales agent works for the builder — helpful, but negotiating for the other side. You can bring your own agent, usually at no cost to you (most builders pay the buyer-agent commission — confirm before you register, and bring your agent to the first visit, since many builders require it). How Krista represents new-construction buyers →

Living Here

What It's Like to Live in Mill Creek Forest

Daily life in Mill Creek Forest is remarkably convenient for a neighborhood tucked among wooded preserves. The Publix Super Market at Shoppes at RiverTown is about a mile away, and Kinder Kafe and Cantina Louie are both within roughly 2 miles for a quick coffee or a casual dinner out. Burn Boot Camp is about 2 miles away for those who prefer a structured fitness routine outside the community, and Aberdeen Park — about 2 miles out — offers open green space for a change of scenery. On weekends, a short drive brings you to The Golf Club at South Hampton or St. Johns Golf & Country Club, and the St. Johns County School District anchors the area's reputation as one of the more desirable pockets of southern St. Johns County.

The Homes

Mill Creek Forest Homes & Architecture

Mill Creek Forest is an exclusively single-family community with homes built primarily from 2023 onward, and a meaningful share of the inventory is still new construction. Architectural styles run from Traditional and Ranch to Patio Home and Contemporary — many featuring the clean lines and open layouts that Toll Brothers is known for in this area. Typical homes offer 3 to 5 bedrooms and 2 to 4 bathrooms across roughly 1,800 to nearly 4,000 square feet, with a median around 2,700 square feet. Prices generally range from the mid-$500s into the low-to-mid $900s. Inside, expect open floorplans with kitchen islands, butler and walk-in pantries, split-bedroom layouts, primary suites on the main floor, soaring ceilings, large sliding glass doors, smart thermostats, and walk-in closets — the kind of finishes that make these homes feel purpose-built rather than pieced together.

Amenities

Mill Creek Forest Amenities & Community Features

Mill Creek Forest is a gated community, so every resident enters through a controlled access point — a detail I find matters quite a bit to buyers coming from more open subdivisions. The community centers on a clubhouse known as the Lodge, surrounded by a resort-style pool, a fitness center, tennis courts, and pickleball courts, giving residents a solid set of active amenities without leaving the neighborhood. A playground, sidewalks, a jogging path, and street lights round out the on-site features, and the HOA covers maintenance of common grounds — monthly fees range from roughly $150 to about $460 depending on the homesite. Notably, Mill Creek Forest carries no CDD fee, which is worth factoring into any cost comparison with nearby communities that do carry one.

Location

Mill Creek Forest Location & Commute

Mill Creek Forest sits in the St. Johns area of southern St. Johns County, positioned conveniently between the St. Johns and St. Augustine corridors. Baptist Medical Center South is about 7 miles away, and The Pavilion at Durbin Park — a major retail hub — is roughly 8 miles out. The beaches at Mickler's Landing and Ponte Vedra Beach are about 17 to 18 miles east, a manageable drive for a weekend outing, and the St. Augustine Historic District is roughly 20 miles south.

Krista Fracke - Broker Associate

Krista Fracke

Your St. Johns Realtor

Now on the Market

All 7 active listings

Showing 7 of 7

Map of Mill Creek Forest listings

New Mill Creek Forest homes, in your inbox

Be first to know when a home lists in Mill Creek Forest. One email, no account needed — and you’ll see everything on the market now the moment you sign up. Owners use these alerts too: every new listing here is your comp set moving.

Free. No spam — unsubscribe in one click.

Questions

Frequently Asked Questions about Mill Creek Forest

Does Mill Creek Forest have a CDD fee?

No — Mill Creek Forest does not carry a Community Development District (CDD) fee, which distinguishes it from a number of other master-planned communities in St. Johns County. Residents do pay a monthly HOA fee, which generally ranges from roughly $150 to about $460 and covers gated access, common-area maintenance, and the community amenity facilities including the pool, fitness center, tennis and pickleball courts, and clubhouse.

How close is Mill Creek Forest to everyday shopping and dining?

The Publix Super Market at Shoppes at RiverTown is about a mile from the community, making it one of the closer grocery options for any neighborhood in this part of St. Johns County. Dining options like Kinder Kafe and Cantina Louie are within about 2 miles, and La Catrina Tacos & Tequila Bar is roughly 3 to 4 miles out. For larger shopping trips, The Pavilion at Durbin Park and The Avenues are both accessible within roughly 8 to 10 miles.

What are the homes like in Mill Creek Forest — are they all new construction?

Mill Creek Forest is a newer community with all homes built from 2023 onward, and a notable share of homes available here are still new construction or recently completed. The community is exclusively single-family, with homes typically ranging from about 1,800 to nearly 4,000 square feet and 3 to 5 bedrooms. Architectural styles include Traditional, Ranch, Patio Home, and Contemporary, and interior finishes commonly feature open floorplans, kitchen islands, split-bedroom layouts, and large sliding glass doors that bring in natural light and preserve views.

How much is my home in Mill Creek Forest worth?

It depends on the comps, and Mill Creek Forest's comps are on this page. Automated estimates are at their worst inside a single neighborhood, where lot position and condition decide the price and the model cannot see either. Follow Mill Creek Forest here and each new listing and sale arrives as it posts, without an account wall or a sales call. A real valuation, prepared against those sales, is one message away.

How long does it take to sell a home in Mill Creek Forest?

Watch the days-on-market figure on this page rather than a headline. Mill Creek Forest's pace runs with its inventory: few homes for sale and a correct price sell quickly, while a crowded month or an optimistic price stretches it. Before we list I read the recent Mill Creek Forest closings against their asking prices and the competition at launch, and the timeline follows from that.

What does it cost to sell a home in Mill Creek Forest?

The list is short; the net is what matters. In Mill Creek Forest, plan on the commission you and I agree on, Florida's documentary stamp tax on the deed (70 cents per $100 of price), title and closing charges that follow local custom, the association's estoppel letter, and, where the home carries one, the community development district line, prorated at closing and disclosed to your buyer; handled correctly it is paperwork, handled late it stalls a contract. I run the net sheet against Mill Creek Forest's actual cost structure before you commit to a number, so the proceeds figure is real.

Neighborhoods nearby: Oxford Estates (0.7 mi, ~6 for sale) · Pinewalk (0.9 mi) · Laurelwood at Esplanade (0.9 mi) · Esplanade at Pinewalk (0.9 mi) · Lakes At Mill Creek Plantation (1.2 mi, ~1 for sale) · Lakes At Mill Creek (1.3 mi, ~2 for sale)

Schools serving Mill Creek Forest

Homes in Mill Creek Forest report these schools in the MLS. Verify current assignments with the district before relying on them.

All St. Johns County Schools →

Charter schools near Mill Creek Forest

Charter schools are tuition-free public schools you apply to. There are no attendance zones, so these are the closest to Mill Creek Forest, by straight-line distance.

Every charter school in the area, with grades and how to apply: Jacksonville charter schools. Checked against each school’s own site October 19, 2026; within 15 miles.

Thinking of selling?

What’s your Mill Creek Forest home worth?

Mill Creek Forest owners use this page the way an appraiser would: every new listing, price change, and MLS-recorded sale in Mill Creek Forest shows up here as it happens. Follow the neighborhood and the market comes to you — free, no spam, and we never sell your data. And when you want a real number for your own home, Krista prepares it personally — no algorithm guesses — backed by 20+ years and 500+ closings in Northeast Florida.

Get my Mill Creek Forest home value →

Interested in Mill Creek Forest?

Krista has 20+ years helping buyers find homes in Northeast Florida, including Mill Creek Forest and St. Johns. Start your search or get personalized recommendations.