Skip to main content
Work directly with Krista on any home hereBroker Associate · 20+ years · 500+ closingsChristie's International Real Estate First Coast

Evergreen Island at Silverleaf Homes For Sale, St. Augustine

St. Augustine, FL

6 homes · median $627,400 · 45 sold in 12 mo at median $562,630 · 70 days avg on market · updated 8 minutes ago

Follow

New Evergreen Island at Silverleaf homes the day they list, by email · free

Narrow Evergreen Island at Silverleaf homes

Market Snapshot

As of November 21, 2026, recent MLS-recorded sales in Evergreen Island at Silverleaf show a median sold price of $562,630 across 45 MLS-recorded sales; 6 homes are currently for sale ($574,940 - $669,990).

Median Sold (12 mo, MLS)
$562,630
▲ 7.8% vs prior 6 mo
Avg. Days to Sell
72 days
Homes Sold (12 mo)
45
For Sale Now
6
HOA Dues
~$167/mo typical

Market stats are based on similar homes in Evergreen Island at Silverleaf, including 45 recent recorded sales — they may not include listings or sales that aren't comparable to this market. Sourced from the MLS; refreshed regularly.

Your beach from Evergreen Island at Silverleaf

The closest public beach accesses with parking from Evergreen Island at Silverleaf, by drive time where we have it, from the county and city beach-access maps.

Beach access near SilverLeaf, mapped →Every public beach access and its parking, on one map →

Sea turtles nest on these beaches May 1 to October 31: the season’s rules. Looking for shark teeth? What you can keep, beach by beach. Dolphins and right whales: when and where to see them.

Public accesses only, from St. Johns County, City of Jacksonville Beach, City of Fernandina Beach and Florida DEP data. Parking counts are approximate, and fees, passes and seasonal rules change; check the posted signs.

Nature near Evergreen Island at Silverleaf

The closest public trail systems and preserves (places with at least a mile of mapped trail or 500 acres), by drive time, from the state, water-district, county and National Park Service maps.

On the water

Fishing the First Coast →Every boat ramp →Every paddle launch →

Sports fields and leagues

  • Durbin Crossing Park

    13 min drive · Baseball, Football, Lacrosse, Softball, Track, Soccer

    Creeks Athletic Association; Julington Creek Baseball; Creeks Girls Lacrosse; +1 more

  • Mill Creek Park

    16 min drive · Baseball

    Villages Baseball Association

  • Veterans Park

    17 min drive · Football, Soccer

    Creeks Flag Football; Sporting Jax Soccer Academy

Youth sports near SilverLeaf, mapped →Every youth league in St. Johns and Duval, by sport →

Parks, trails and boat ramps near SilverLeaf, mapped →Every state and national park within two hours →The springs, by drive time →

Public lands only; ramps and launches from FWC’s inventory, straight-line distance. Trail miles are what the managing agency maps; hours, fees, hunting seasons and closures change, so check the agency’s page before you go.

Groceries near Evergreen Island at Silverleaf

The closest store of each big chain, by drive time, from the middle of Evergreen Island at Silverleaf.

Grocery stores near SilverLeaf, mapped →Every big-chain grocery store in St. Johns, Duval and Nassau →

Stores holding a state retail food permit, located from each chain’s own store list. Drive times are typical, without traffic.

The Neighborhood

About Evergreen Island at Silverleaf, St. Augustine

  • Community Type:
    Gated CommunityNew Construction AvailableMaster-Planned Community
  • Property Type:
    Single Family Homes
  • Amenities:
    Community PoolTennis CourtsPickleball CourtsClubhousePlaygroundDog Park

Touring model homes here? The on-site sales agent works for the builder — helpful, but negotiating for the other side. You can bring your own agent, usually at no cost to you (most builders pay the buyer-agent commission — confirm before you register, and bring your agent to the first visit, since many builders require it). How Krista represents new-construction buyers →

Living Here

What It's Like to Live in Evergreen Island at Silverleaf

Daily errands and major retail are anchored by The Pavilion at Durbin Park, roughly 6 miles away, with a broad mix of national retailers and restaurants. For a longer outing, the St. Augustine Premium Outlets are about 9 miles south, and the St. Augustine Historic District — cobblestone streets, dining, and centuries of history — is roughly 16 miles away. Buyers who enjoy the outdoors have the Guana Tolomato Matanzas Research Reserve about 12 miles away, a 76,000-acre coastal wilderness with beach, salt marsh, hiking, and birding. For dining, Aqua Grill in Sawgrass Village and Cap's on the Water on the Intracoastal are both within about 15–18 miles — a straightforward drive that residents here seem to make regularly.

The Homes

Evergreen Island at Silverleaf Homes & Architecture

Homes in Evergreen Island at Silverleaf are all new construction, built in 2026, and run from about 2,400 to just over 3,000 square feet of living space. The mix is entirely single-family, typically with 3 to 5 bedrooms and 2.5 to 3.5 bathrooms — with 4 bedrooms being the most common configuration. Interiors are designed around open-concept living, featuring kitchen islands, eat-in kitchens, walk-in pantries, split bedroom layouts, and primary suites on the main level with entrance foyers and walk-in closets. Several floor plans incorporate 10-foot ceilings and 8-foot interior doors on the main level, and wooded or cul-de-sac homesites are a recurring feature. I don't publish fee numbers that can go stale. When you're serious about a home here, I pull the current HOA and assessment figures for that exact lot.

Amenities

Evergreen Island at Silverleaf Amenities & Community Features

Evergreen Island at Silverleaf is a gated community with full-time, on-site management and maintenance of common grounds — details that matter when you're evaluating what your HOA dollar actually covers. The community includes a pool, a children's pool, a clubhouse, a dog park, a park area, and pickleball courts. Sidewalks and street lights run throughout, making it easy to get around on foot. Johns County master-planned communities.

Location

Evergreen Island at Silverleaf Location & Commute

Evergreen Island sits within the Silverleaf master plan in northern St. Johns County, roughly mid-way between the St. Augustine Historic District and the Duval County line. Baptist Medical Center South is about 12 miles away, Flagler Health+ Village at St. Augustine is roughly 15 miles south, and Mayo Clinic Florida is about 17 miles to the north. Mickler's Landing Beach in Ponte Vedra is approximately 16 miles away, and Vilano Beach — a quieter option just north of St. Augustine — is about 16 miles as well. Jacksonville International Airport is roughly 34 miles north. For school assignments, verify your specific address with the St. Johns County School District before relying on any zoning information.

Schools

Schools Near Evergreen Island at Silverleaf

Evergreen Island at Silverleaf is zoned for Magnolia Oaks Academy at both the elementary and middle school levels, and for Tocoi Creek High School, all within the St. Johns County School District. As always, school assignments are address-specific — confirm zoning for any particular home directly with the district before making decisions based on school boundaries.

Krista Fracke - Broker Associate

Krista Fracke

Your St. Augustine Realtor

Now on the Market

All 6 Evergreen Island at Silverleaf homes for sale

Showing 6 of 6

Map of Evergreen Island at Silverleaf listings

New Evergreen Island at Silverleaf homes, in your inbox

Be first to know when a home lists in Evergreen Island at Silverleaf. One email address is all it takes, and you’ll see everything on the market now the moment you sign up. Owners use these alerts too: every new listing here is your comp set moving.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click.

Questions

Frequently Asked Questions about Evergreen Island at Silverleaf

Does Evergreen Island at Silverleaf have CDD fees?

Association and district assessments here change year to year, so I confirm the current figures for any home you consider instead of quoting a number that may be stale. When you're serious about a home here, I pull the current HOA and assessment figures for that exact lot. Buyers coming from other new St. Johns County master-planned communities often flag this as a meaningful cost difference.

What is the commute like from Evergreen Island to Jacksonville or the Beaches?

Evergreen Island is situated in northern St. Johns County, which puts it within a reasonable drive of both Jacksonville's Southside and the Ponte Vedra Beach corridor. Major retail and services at The Pavilion at Durbin Park are about 6 miles away, and Mickler's Landing Beach is roughly 16 miles. Jacksonville International Airport is about 34 miles north. Traffic along the I-95 and US-1 corridors can vary during peak hours, so buyers commuting regularly to Jacksonville should take a test drive at their typical commute time.

Are all homes in Evergreen Island new construction?

Based on what's been coming to market, yes — the homes in Evergreen Island at Silverleaf are newly built, with construction dated to 2026. Floor plans have ranged from about 2,400 to just over 3,000 square feet, with 3 to 5 bedrooms. The community sits within the broader Silverleaf master plan, which includes other neighborhoods at varying price points and stages of development.

Neighborhoods nearby: Waterford Lakes (0.6 mi, ~12 for sale) · Brook Forest (0.7 mi, ~20 for sale) · Courtney Oaks (1.3 mi, ~5 for sale) · Silver Meadows (1.3 mi, ~21 for sale) · Holly Forest (1.3 mi, ~7 for sale) · Bartram Downs (1.4 mi)

Charter schools near Evergreen Island at Silverleaf

Charter schools are tuition-free public schools you apply to. There are no attendance zones, so these are the closest to Evergreen Island at Silverleaf, by straight-line distance.

Every charter school in the area, with grades and how to apply: Jacksonville charter schools. Checked against each school’s own site October 19, 2026; within 15 miles.

Thinking of selling?

What’s your Evergreen Island at Silverleaf home worth?

Evergreen Island at Silverleaf owners use this page the way an appraiser would: every new listing, price change, and MLS-recorded sale in Evergreen Island at Silverleaf shows up here as it happens. Follow the neighborhood and the market comes to you. And when you want a real number for your own home, Krista prepares it personally — no algorithm guesses — backed by 20+ years and 500+ closings in Northeast Florida.

Get my Evergreen Island at Silverleaf home value →

Interested in Evergreen Island at Silverleaf?

Krista has 20+ years helping buyers find homes in Northeast Florida, including Evergreen Island at Silverleaf and St. Augustine. Start your search or get personalized recommendations.