Evergreen Island at Silverleaf Homes For Sale, St. Augustine

Daily errands and major retail are anchored by The Pavilion at Durbin Park, roughly 6 miles away, with a broad mix of national retailers and restaurants. For a longer outing, the St. Augustine Premium Outlets are about 9 miles south, and the St. Augustine Historic District — cobblestone streets, dining, and centuries of history — is roughly 16 miles away. Buyers who enjoy the outdoors have the Guana Tolomato Matanzas Research Reserve about 12 miles away, a 76,000-acre coastal wilderness with beach, salt marsh, hiking, and birding. For dining, Aqua Grill in Sawgrass Village and Cap's on the Water on the Intracoastal are both within about 15–18 miles — a straightforward drive that residents here seem to make regularly.

Homes in Evergreen Island at Silverleaf are all new construction, built in 2026, and run from about 2,400 to just over 3,000 square feet of living space. The mix is entirely single-family, typically with 3 to 5 bedrooms and 2.5 to 3.5 bathrooms — with 4 bedrooms being the most common configuration. Interiors are designed around open-concept living, featuring kitchen islands, eat-in kitchens, walk-in pantries, split bedroom layouts, and primary suites on the main level with entrance foyers and walk-in closets. Several floor plans incorporate 10-foot ceilings and 8-foot interior doors on the main level, and wooded or cul-de-sac homesites are a recurring feature. I don't publish fee numbers that can go stale. When you're serious about a home here, I pull the current HOA and assessment figures for that exact lot.

Evergreen Island at Silverleaf is a gated community with full-time, on-site management and maintenance of common grounds — details that matter when you're evaluating what your HOA dollar actually covers. The community includes a pool, a children's pool, a clubhouse, a dog park, a park area, and pickleball courts. Sidewalks and street lights run throughout, making it easy to get around on foot. Johns County master-planned communities.

Evergreen Island sits within the Silverleaf master plan in northern St. Johns County, roughly mid-way between the St. Augustine Historic District and the Duval County line. Baptist Medical Center South is about 12 miles away, Flagler Health+ Village at St. Augustine is roughly 15 miles south, and Mayo Clinic Florida is about 17 miles to the north. Mickler's Landing Beach in Ponte Vedra is approximately 16 miles away, and Vilano Beach — a quieter option just north of St. Augustine — is about 16 miles as well. Jacksonville International Airport is roughly 34 miles north. For school assignments, verify your specific address with the St. Johns County School District before relying on any zoning information.

Evergreen Island at Silverleaf is zoned for Magnolia Oaks Academy at both the elementary and middle school levels, and for Tocoi Creek High School, all within the St. Johns County School District. As always, school assignments are address-specific — confirm zoning for any particular home directly with the district before making decisions based on school boundaries.