Stillwater Homes For Sale, St. Johns

Daily life in Stillwater revolves around the community's own resort amenities, but the surrounding area adds genuine convenience. Sprouts Farmers Market and Publix at Johns Creek Center are both within about a mile and a half, and La Catrina Tacos & Tequila Bar — one of the most popular spots in this corridor — is just over a mile away. Ember & Iron offers a sit-down American dining option barely a mile and a half out, while Kinder Kafe handles the morning coffee stop at roughly the same distance. Veterans Park, about 2 miles away, brings well-rated green space and a dedicated dog park into reach, and the Red Blaze and White Blaze Trails about 3 miles out give residents natural-surface walking and running options beyond the neighborhood sidewalks.

Homes in Stillwater are exclusively single-family — primarily villas built between 2021 and 2025, in villa, traditional, and ranch styles. Typical floor plans run from about 1,500 to around 2,100 square feet, with 2 to 4 bedrooms and 2 to 3 bathrooms; most homes land around 3 bedrooms and roughly 1,750 square feet. Prices generally range from the low $300s into the upper $600s, with a median around the low $400s. Interior finishes common throughout the community include open floorplans, kitchen islands with quartz countertops, gas ranges, double ovens, walk-in closets, split bedroom layouts, and primary suites on the main floor — a configuration that works particularly well in single-story plans. Monthly HOA fees run roughly $660 to $740 and cover golf membership, lawn maintenance, and pest control, which is a meaningful part of the value calculation buyers need to factor in.

Stillwater is a gated community built around an 18-hole Bobby Weed golf course, and the HOA includes golf membership in the monthly fee — something that distinguishes it from most area communities where memberships are purchased separately. The clubhouse anchors daily social life, offering a full restaurant with lunch and dinner service. Beyond golf, residents have access to a community pool, fitness center, tennis courts, pickleball courts, and a network of sidewalks with street lighting throughout the neighborhood. Grounds maintenance is also covered, which means residents are largely freed from exterior upkeep — a defining feature of how this community is structured.

Stillwater sits in the St. Johns area of St. Johns County, with Cimarrone Golf Club less than a mile away and Sprouts and Publix reachable in under 10 minutes. Baptist Medical Center South is about 5 miles out, and The Pavilion at Durbin Park — a major retail and dining destination — is roughly 6 miles away. The nearest Atlantic beaches, including Mickler's Landing, are about 15 miles east, and the St. Augustine Historic District and St. George Street are roughly 20 miles south, making weekend day trips straightforward. In the years I've worked in this part of St. Johns County, the accessibility along this corridor has improved steadily, and the concentration of services within a few miles of Stillwater makes the location genuinely practical.

Stillwater listings report Timberlin Creek Elementary, Switzerland Point Middle School and Beachside High School, all in the St. Johns County School District. School assignments are address-specific and change; confirm the zoning for any specific home with the district before you buy.