St. Johns County
Mill Creek Forest Homes For Sale, St. Johns
St. Johns, FL
FollowWhy buyers stay
Market Snapshot
As of July 23, 2026, the median list price in Mill Creek Forest is $668,500 across 12 active listings, averaging $251/sqft; the median sold price over the last 12 months is $625,000 across 9 MLS-recorded sales.
Figures reflect recent market activity in Mill Creek Forest, including 9 sales over the last 12 months — not only the homes listed for sale today. Sourced from MLS data; refreshed regularly.
Mill Creek Forest Home Values
The MLS-recorded sales above are what homes in Mill Creek Forest actually sell for — and the comp set your future buyer will see. Own a home here? This page updates with every new listing, price change, and recorded sale, so following it is the simplest way to watch your equity. There’s no automated estimate on this site — when you want a real number, Krista prepares it personally against these sales.
HOA dues:~$154/mo typical
- Median List Price
- $668,500
- Avg. Price / Sq Ft
- $251/sqft
- Median Sold (12 mo, MLS)
- $625,000
- 9 sales
- Active Listings
- 12
The Neighborhood
About Mill Creek Forest, St. Johns

Krista Fracke
Your St. Johns Realtor
Now on the Market
Mill Creek Forest Homes For Sale(10)
Showing 10 of 10
Active$895,000MLS# 2147129Est. $4,764/mo101 Elm Branch Road, St. Johns, FL 322595 Beds4 Baths3,848 sqftResidentialDOORVINE REALTY LLC
Active$768,000MLS# 2140370Est. $4,088/mo210 Mason Branch Drive, St. Johns, FL 322594 Beds3 Baths3,250 sqftResidentialJACKSONVILLE TBI REALTY, LLC
Active$728,000MLS# 2149647Est. $3,875/mo47 Callaway Circle, St. Johns, FL 322594 Beds4 Baths3,247 sqftResidentialJACKSONVILLE TBI REALTY, LLC
Active$698,000MLS# 2140367Est. $3,715/mo36 Dalton Mill Drive, St. Johns, FL 322594 Beds3 Baths2,866 sqftResidentialJACKSONVILLE TBI REALTY, LLC
Active$679,000MLS# 2126461Est. $3,614/mo81 Erlking Court, St. Johns, FL 322594 Beds3 Baths3,358 sqftResidentialUNITED REAL ESTATE GALLERY
Active$575,000MLS# 2154221Est. $3,060/mo120 Dalton Mill Drive, St. Johns, FL 322593 Beds2 Baths1,801 sqftResidentialBERKSHIRE HATHAWAY HOMESERVICES FLORIDA REALTY
Active$551,999MLS# 2146859Est. $2,938/mo131 Bridgeton Street, Jacksonville, FL 322593 Beds2 Baths2,170 sqftResidentialSIMP REALTY GROUP LLC
Active Under Contract$538,000MLS# 2112668Est. $2,863/mo274 Valley Falls Way, St. Johns, FL 322594 Beds3 Baths2,496 sqftResidentialREAL BROKER LLC
Active$514,900MLS# 2149007Est. $2,741/mo272 Wye Road, St. Johns, FL 322593 Beds2 Baths1,801 sqftResidentialPUBLIC SERVICES REALTY
Active$497,000MLS# 2133350Est. $2,645/mo42 Mason Branch Drive, St. Johns, FL 322593 Beds2 Baths1,800 sqftResidentialJACKSONVILLE TBI REALTY, LLC
Map of Mill Creek Forest listings
New Mill Creek Forest homes, in your inbox
Be first to know when a home lists in Mill Creek Forest. One email, no account needed — and you’ll see everything on the market now the moment you sign up. Owners use these alerts too: every new listing here is your comp set moving.
Free. No spam — unsubscribe in one click.
Questions
Frequently Asked Questions about Mill Creek Forest
How much is my home in Mill Creek Forest worth?
There’s no automated estimate on this site, on purpose — algorithms average a zip code, and your value turns on the specifics an average can’t see: condition, position, and what the last few Mill Creek Forest sales actually closed for. Every new listing and MLS-recorded sale in Mill Creek Forest surfaces on this page as it happens, so following it is the simplest way to watch your comp set move. When you want a real number, Krista prepares it personally against Mill Creek Forest’s own sales — no algorithm guesses, no obligation.
How long does it take to sell a home in Mill Creek Forest?
It depends on the market you list into, not the market you read about — and this page tracks Mill Creek Forest’s pace the honest way, from live MLS activity rather than a static average. The market snapshot above reflects what’s actually happening here right now, and it shifts: the answer in a tight-inventory spring is different from a heavy-inventory fall. Before we ever set a price or a timeline, I read Mill Creek Forest’s current pace — days on market, how recent sales closed against their list prices, and what your home’s specific competition looks like the week we launch.
What does it cost to sell a home in Mill Creek Forest?
A few lines beyond the obvious ones. In Mill Creek Forest, plan on: the commission you and Krista agree on, Florida’s documentary stamp tax on the deed, title and closing charges per local custom, the association’s estoppel letter — and because this community carries a district assessment, the CDD line is prorated at closing and must be disclosed to your buyer, which is a paperwork step, not a penalty. Priced and disclosed correctly, it never kills a deal; handled sloppily, it stalls one. Krista runs the full seller’s net sheet against Mill Creek Forest’s actual cost structure before you commit to a number.
Schools serving Mill Creek Forest
Homes in Mill Creek Forest report these schools in the MLS. Verify current assignments with the district before relying on them.
- Bartram Trail High SchoolHigh
- Switzerland Point Middle SchoolMiddle
- Cunningham Creek ElementaryElementary
- Timberlin Creek ElementaryElementary
Thinking of selling?
What’s your Mill Creek Forest home worth?
Mill Creek Forest owners use this page the way an appraiser would: every new listing, price change, and MLS-recorded sale in Mill Creek Forest shows up here as it happens. Follow the neighborhood and the market comes to you — free, no spam, and we never sell your data. And when you want a real number for your own home, Krista prepares it personally — no algorithm guesses — backed by 20+ years and 500+ closings in Northeast Florida.
Get my Mill Creek Forest home value →Interested in Mill Creek Forest?
Krista has 20+ years helping buyers find homes in Mill Creek Forest and St. Johns. Start your search or get personalized recommendations.










