Skip to main content
Work directly with Krista on any home hereBroker Associate · 20+ years · 500+ closingsChristie's International Real Estate First Coast

Fleming Island

Homes for Sale in Fleming Island

98 homes · 7 new this week · median $452,500 · 387 sold in 12 mo at median $459,900 · 66 days avg on market · updated 19 minutes ago

New homes in Fleming Island the day they list, by email · free
Text Krista

Market Snapshot

As of November 20, 2026, the median list price for homes in Fleming Island is $452,500 across 98 active listings, averaging $211/sqft; recent MLS-recorded sales show a median sold price of $459,900 across 387 closings.

Median List Price
$452,500
Avg. Price / Sq Ft
$211/sqft
Median Sold (12 mo, MLS)
$459,900
▲ 6.3% vs prior 6 mo
Active Listings
98
HOA Dues
~$39/mo typical
88 of 98 listings carry dues

Market stats are based on homes in Fleming Island, including 387 recent recorded sales — they may not include listings or sales that aren't comparable to this market. Sourced from the MLS; refreshed regularly.

All 98 Homes for Sale in Fleming Island

Showing 98 of 98

Closed sales

What homes in Fleming Island actually sold for

Median closed price by year from the MLS, 2019 to 2026: down 3% since 2025. 358 sales closed in 2026 at a median $212 per square foot.

$444K19$390K20$410K21$495K22$430K23$495K24$480K25$465K26$0$495K
YearSalesMedian sold$/sq ftOf askingDays on market
20196 †$444K$13797.8%49
202011 †$390K$14097.7%41
202127 †$410K$169100%21
202217 †$495K$201100.3%23
202324 †$430K$20598%39
202488 †$495K$20997.9%32
2025339$480K$21298.1%35
2026358$465K$21298.4%23

Closed sales from the realMLS IDX feed; years with fewer than three sales are omitted. Medians, not estimates of any one home. "Of asking" is the median sold price as a share of the final list price. † A partial year in the feed: it carries only some of that year’s sales, so the median rests on fewer homes and the percent change above starts at the first full year.

This market, from the inside

Fleming Island sits along the St. Johns River in Clay County, just south of Orange Park and a short drive from downtown Jacksonville. It’s an established community known for its master-planned neighborhoods — including Eagle Harbor, Pace Island, and Fleming Island Plantation — along with golf, parks, and abundant water access. Bordered by the St. Johns River, Doctors Lake, Black Creek, and Swimming Pen Creek, the area pairs everyday convenience along the US-17 corridor with a relaxed, riverside setting.

Fleming Island suits buyers looking for an established suburban community with a range of housing styles, Clay County District schools, and amenities like golf and waterfront recreation. Filter the listings below by price, size, and features — and reach out anytime with questions or to arrange a showing.

Frequently asked questions

What are the main neighborhoods in Fleming Island?

Several master-planned communities, most notably Eagle Harbor, Pace Island, and Fleming Island Plantation. Eagle Harbor is among the largest, offering golf and a variety of residential neighborhoods within it.

Where is Fleming Island located?

An unincorporated community in Clay County on the west side of the St. Johns River along US-17, just south of Orange Park and roughly 20 miles from downtown Jacksonville, bordered by the river, Doctors Lake, Black Creek, and Swimming Pen Creek.

Looking for in Fleming Island?

I’ll send new listings the moment they hit the market and walk through the details that don’t show up in the MLS — water access, HOA rules, what a feature really costs to maintain.

Thinking of selling?

What’s your Greater Northeast Florida home worth?

The sales above are the comp set a buyer will see. When you want a real number for your own home, Krista prepares it personally — no algorithm guesses — from the MLS-recorded sales in Greater Northeast Florida, backed by 20+ years and 500+ closings in Northeast Florida.

Get my Greater Northeast Florida home value →
Text