Eagle Harbor Homes For Sale

Day-to-day life in Eagle Harbor revolves around a community that packs in more than most — residents have access to a golf course, community pools, tennis and pickleball courts, a boat dock, jogging paths, and a playground without leaving the neighborhood. When the mood calls for something farther afield, The Avenues Mall is about 13 miles away, and St. Johns Town Center — with more than 175 stores — is roughly 16 miles out. Fine dining in Jacksonville's Avondale and San Marco neighborhoods, including Restaurant Orsay and Matthew's Restaurant, is about 15 miles from Eagle Harbor's front gates. What surprises buyers touring here is how self-contained the community feels for a Clay County address — the amenity list reads more like a resort than a typical suburb.

Homes in Eagle Harbor run from roughly 2,300 to about 4,000 square feet of living space, with 3 to 5 bedrooms and 2 to 4 bathrooms — the typical home lands around 2,750 square feet with 4 bedrooms. The dominant architectural styles are Traditional, Ranch, and Contemporary, and the construction era spans 1996 to 2010, so buyers will find established streetscapes with mature landscaping throughout. Inside, open floorplans with split-bedroom layouts are common, and many homes feature kitchen islands, breakfast bars, eat-in kitchens, walk-in closets, and a primary suite on the main level. About a third of homes have private pools, and roughly a third sit on waterfront lots — often overlooking ponds or the golf course. I don't publish fee numbers that can go stale. When you're serious about a home here, I pull the current HOA and assessment figures for that exact lot.

Eagle Harbor's community amenities are one of its most defining characteristics — residents have access to a golf course, a clubhouse, two pools (including a children's pool), basketball and tennis courts, pickleball, a jogging path, a playground, a boat dock, sidewalks throughout, and a park. The combination of golf and water access on a single community footprint is relatively uncommon in Clay County, and buyers consistently flag the amenity depth when comparing Eagle Harbor to neighboring communities.

Eagle Harbor sits in Fleming Island in the heart of Clay County, roughly 12 miles from Baptist Medical Center South and about 13 miles from The Avenues Mall in Jacksonville's Southside corridor. Downtown Jacksonville and the major medical campuses along Riverside — including Ascension St. Vincent's and Baptist Medical Center Jacksonville — are approximately 15 miles away, typically a 25-to-30-minute drive depending on traffic on US-17. The Atlantic coast beaches, including Mickler's Landing and Ponte Vedra Beach, are roughly 23 miles east, and Jacksonville International Airport is about 27 miles to the north. St. Augustine's historic district is around 29 miles south — an easy day trip.

Schools serving this area include Fleming Island Elementary, Thunderbolt Elementary, and Paterson Elementary at the elementary level, with Lakeside Middle and Green Cove Springs Middle serving the middle grades, and Fleming Island High School at the secondary level — all part of the Clay County District Schools. Because Eagle Harbor spans multiple school zones, assignments are address-specific; always verify your particular address with the district's school locator before relying on any zoning information.