Skip to main content

What’s Your Home Worth

Reserve at James Island Home Values

The Real Number

Algorithms estimate. This page shows what Reserve at James Island homes actually sell for — live from the MLS — and how Krista turns those sales into a real number for your specific home. No automated estimate, no obligation, and we never sell your data.

— Krista

Get my Reserve at James Island home value →

The Reserve at James Island market right now

Based on 23 MLS-recorded sales in the last 12 months and 12 active listings.

Median sold price
$180,000
▼ 5.4% YoY
Median $/sq ft
$159
Typical sale range
$150,000–$220,000
a starting range, not your number
Active listings
12
median $199,900

See every Reserve at James Island sale, with prices →·Browse homes for sale in Reserve at James Island →

What sold in Reserve at James Island recently

The newest 12 of 23 MLS-recorded sales in the last 12 months. Closed prices, not estimates; each address opens the home’s own record.

AddressClosedSold$/sq ftBd/Ba
10961 Burnt Mill Road #1524Listed by THE LEGENDS OF REAL ESTATEOct 2026$150,000$1841/1
10961 Burnt Mill Road 414Listed by HOUWZER, INC.Oct 2026$237,000$2022/2
10961 Burnt Mill Road 828Listed by WATSON REALTY CORPJun 2026$205,000$1762/2
10961 Burnt Mill Road 1021Listed by CHRISTIE'S INTERNATIONAL REAL ESTATE FIRST COASTJun 2026$170,000$1462/2
10961 Burnt Mill Road 1213Listed by MOMENTUM REALTYMay 2026$140,000$1721/1
10961 Burnt Mill Road 1628Listed by KELLER WILLIAMS ST JOHNSMay 2026$220,000$1623/2
10961 Burnt Mill Road 1115Listed by UNITED REAL ESTATE GALLERYMay 2026$195,000$1672/2
10961 Burnt Mill Road 333Listed by NEEDHAM REALTY GROUPMay 2026$177,160$1382/2
10961 Burnt Mill Road 1217Listed by COMPASS FLORIDA LLCApr 2026$190,000$1592/2
10961 Burnt Mill Road 317Listed by KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY ATLANTIC PARTNERSApr 2026$217,000$1822/2
10961 Burnt Mill Road 1017Listed by CROSSVIEW REALTYApr 2026$178,000$1532/2
10961 Burnt Mill Road 1132Listed by BERRY & CO. REAL ESTATEMar 2026$230,000$1932/2

Sold data from the realMLS IDX feed. Medians describe Reserve at James Island; none of this is an estimate of your home.

Every Reserve at James Island sale in the last 12 months →

Home values nearby: Oxford Chase Townhomes (0.2 mi, 8 sold in 12 mo) · Brightwater Townhomes (0.3 mi, 14 sold in 12 mo) · James Island (0.3 mi, 10 sold in 12 mo) · Tidal Pointe (0.7 mi, 7 sold in 12 mo) · Pointe Meadows (0.8 mi, 14 sold in 12 mo) · Point Meadows Place (0.8 mi, 14 sold in 12 mo)

How Krista prices your Reserve at James Island home

  1. The real comp set. Every recent Reserve at James Island sale, read individually — what condition it sold in, how it was positioned, and what it closed for against its asking price.
  2. Your home’s specifics. Lot, position, condition, and the cost lines a buyer here will price in — the details an algorithm averages away.
  3. A number you can act on. A written valuation prepared personally by Krista Fracke — yours whether or not you list, with a net-proceeds picture, not just a price.

Get my free home valuation

Reviewed by Krista Fracke personally·20+ years·500+ closings

Selling in Reserve at James Island: what owners ask

What do HOA fees cover at Reserve At James Island, and how much should I budget?

Monthly HOA fees at Reserve At James Island generally range from the $330s to about $540, depending on the unit. The fees cover amenities access, trash service, grounds maintenance, and off-site management. Buyers should factor this into their monthly cost calculations alongside their mortgage payment, as it adds meaningfully to the carrying cost compared to a standard single-family home.

How close is Reserve At James Island to the beaches?

Jacksonville Beach and Ponte Vedra Beach are both roughly nine miles from the community, and Neptune Beach is about the same distance. In typical traffic, that translates to a manageable drive for weekend outings. The location is better suited to those who want easy weekday access to Southside employers, Mayo Clinic, and St. Johns Town Center, with the beach as a reasonable weekend option rather than a daily destination.

What types of homes are available at Reserve At James Island?

The community is made up entirely of condominiums built in 2001, ranging from about 800 to roughly 1,350 square feet with one to three bedrooms. A small share of units have lake or water views. The traditional-style buildings are well-landscaped, and units commonly feature open layouts, private balconies, and walk-in closets — making them well-suited for those seeking low-maintenance living near the Southside's amenities.

How much is my home in Reserve at James Island worth?

No instant estimate here, by design. Automated values average a ZIP code, and a Reserve at James Island home's value turns on what an average cannot see: condition, position on the street, and what the last few Reserve at James Island sales actually closed for. Every new listing and recorded sale in Reserve at James Island appears on this page as it happens, so following it is the simplest way to watch your comp set move. When you want a real number, I prepare it against Reserve at James Island's own sales, with no obligation.

How long does it take to sell a home in Reserve at James Island?

It depends on the market you list into, not the one you read about. The snapshot on this page tracks Reserve at James Island's pace from live MLS activity rather than a static average, and it shifts: a tight-inventory spring and a heavy-inventory fall give different answers. Before setting a price or a timeline, I read Reserve at James Island's current pace, how recent sales closed against their list prices, and what your home's competition looks like the week we launch.

What does it cost to sell a home in Reserve at James Island?

Condo sales carry a few lines single-family sales don’t, and knowing them up front is how you protect your net. In Reserve at James Island, plan on: the commission you and Krista agree on, Florida’s documentary stamp tax on the deed, title and closing charges per local custom, the association’s estoppel letter, and — because this is a condominium — the buyer’s side will ask for the association’s current budget, reserve information, and any inspection reports, so having those ready is part of selling well here. A well-documented association is a selling point; Krista assembles that package with you before the listing goes live.

Watching rather than selling? The Reserve at James Island page updates with every listing, price change, and MLS-recorded sale — following it is the simplest way to watch your equity.