Skip to main content
St. Johns County streetscape

Moving to St. Johns County: what to know before you pick a corridor.

Most people who call me about St. Johns County have already decided on Florida and are choosing between here and somewhere in Jacksonville. I’m Krista Fracke, and I have sold in this county for two decades, so this is the page I wish they had read first: how the county is actually organized, which cost lines catch relocating buyers off guard, how the commute really works, and how to think about schools without believing a marketing line.

Krista Fracke - Broker Associate

By Krista Fracke — Broker Associate, Christie's International Real Estate First Coast · 20+ years in Northeast Florida · 500+ closings · client reviews

The market right now: 3,549 homes are currently for sale in St. Johns County, with a median asking price of $493,990. St. Johns County homes for sale →

Live from the MLS · refreshed daily

The shape of the county

St. Johns County is a long rectangle between the Atlantic and the St. Johns River, with St. Augustine as the county seat at its southern end and Ponte Vedra Beach at the northern tip. Almost everything in between is unincorporated county, which is why so many addresses say "St. Augustine" or "Ponte Vedra" for homes that are nowhere near either. Buyers who search by city name miss most of the inventory.

The practical map is corridors, not cities. The coast runs Ponte Vedra Beach, Nocatee, Vilano, St. Augustine and the beaches south of it. The CR-210 corridor and Julington Creek sit along the Duval line for Jacksonville commuters. World Golf Village, Palencia and the newer master-planned communities fill the middle along I-95 and US-1. RiverTown and SilverLeaf anchor the west side toward the river. Each corridor has its own price band, builder era and commute, and the page for each is linked below.

66 Latham Drive, Ponte Vedra, FL 32081
See all photos
On the market in St. Johns County · Active
$579,000
66 Latham Drive, Ponte Vedra, FL 32081
3 BD · 3 BA · 2,051 SQFT
Listed by BETTER HOMES & GARDENS REAL ESTATE LIFESTYLES REALTY
St. Johns County homes for sale →

What daily life runs on

The county grew around master-planned communities, and most of the homes built in the last twenty years sit inside one. That means amenity centers, trail systems and events calendars, and it also means Community Development District assessments on the tax bill that fund them. Which communities carry a CDD, and roughly what it does to a payment, is on the county CDD page linked below; the live table on each community page shows the HOA side.

Outside the master plans, the older neighborhoods along the coast and around downtown St. Augustine run on a different logic: fewer shared amenities, more character, older roofs and older insurance questions. I show both kinds every week, and the right answer depends on how you want to spend a Saturday.

On the market in St. Johns County · Active
$450,000
216 Riverwalk Boulevard, St. Johns, FL 32259
3 BD · 2 BA · 1,773 SQFT
Listed by RE/MAX SPECIALISTS
St. Johns County homes for sale →

The cost lines that surprise relocating buyers

Florida has no state income tax, and that is usually the first reason people call. The lines that replace it are property tax at your purchase price (the previous owner’s bill tells you nothing, because the Save Our Homes cap resets on sale), homeowner’s insurance that varies more by roof age and construction than by price, and any CDD or HOA the community carries. I lay all of those out on the true monthly cost section of every listing on this site, and the tax-math page linked below walks the state-to-state comparison.

The commute, truthfully

Most St. Johns County households work somewhere else. I-95 and US-1 carry the county to Jacksonville’s Southside and downtown, 9B connects the northern corridors to the Southside employers, and A1A serves the coast. The northern corridors are a daily commute for many Jacksonville workers; from the St. Augustine end it is a longer proposition that people accept for the lifestyle. Before you commit to a corridor, drive it at the hour you would actually drive it. I will tell you which junctions pinch and when.

Schools, without the marketing line

St. Johns County runs one county-wide public school district, and homes are assigned to schools by attendance zone, which the district revises as it builds. Two houses on the same street can zone differently after a boundary change. The zoning is a fact to verify for the specific address before you write an offer, not a reputation to buy on. My school pages show the homes currently zoned to each school so you can start from the school and work back to the house.

The honest cons

Every place worth living in has them. These are the ones I make sure my own buyers weigh before they commit — not after.

The CDD is a real line, for decades

The amenity engine most newer communities sell on is financed by a district assessment that rides the tax bill and typically runs for the life of the bond. It is disclosed, but out-of-state buyers comparing list prices routinely leave it out of the math.

Everything is a drive

The county is car-dependent by design. Groceries, schools, the beach and the office are separate trips, and the newer corridors are still adding the retail that catches up with the rooftops.

Construction is a way of life in the growth corridors

Buying into an actively building community means construction traffic, dust and a streetscape that finishes years after you close. The established corridors trade that for older homes and older systems.

Coastal homes carry coastal questions

Flood zone, elevation, roof age and wind mitigation drive insurance on the coast in a way inland buyers have never dealt with. The Reality Check on every listing here shows the flood and evacuation zones before you fall in love.

The part nobody tells you

The county’s reputation travels ahead of its geography, and buyers pay a premium for the name on the mailing address whether or not the house sits near the thing they were picturing. A "Ponte Vedra" address can be twenty minutes from the ocean; a "St. Augustine" address can be twenty minutes from the historic district. Before you pay for a name, look at the map, the commute and the zoning for the specific parcel. I do that for every buyer I work with, in the first conversation.

This is the work I do every week. Relocating here? Tell me where you work, what your week looks like and what you are leaving behind, and I will tell you which corridors fit and what the honest monthly number is in each. No sign-up, no list you did not ask for.

Work with Krista (904) 333-8595 Text

Broker Associate · Christie's International Real Estate First Coast · 20+ years · 500+ closings

Common questions

Is St. Johns County a good place to move to?

For buyers who want newer master-planned communities, coast access and a Florida tax structure, it is one of the strongest options in the state. The trade-offs are car dependence, district assessments in most newer communities, and construction in the growth corridors. The corridor you choose matters more than the county name.

What is the difference between Ponte Vedra Beach and a Ponte Vedra address?

Ponte Vedra Beach is the coastal community at the county’s northern tip. "Ponte Vedra" is the mailing city for a much larger inland area, including all of Nocatee. Same postal name, different places, different price bands. Check the map, not the mailing city.

Do all St. Johns County communities have CDD fees?

No. Most of the newer master-planned communities carry one; the older coastal and downtown neighborhoods and some newer communities, SilverLeaf among them, do not. The county CDD page lists which is which, and I confirm the exact line for any home you consider.

How do I know which school a house is zoned to?

By the district’s attendance zone for that specific address, which can change as the district builds. I verify it per address before an offer, and my school pages show the homes currently zoned to each school.

How far is the commute to Jacksonville from St. Johns County?

It depends entirely on the corridor. The CR-210, Julington Creek and Nocatee corridors are everyday commutes to the Southside via 9B and I-95. From St. Augustine it is a longer daily drive that people choose for the lifestyle. Drive your corridor at your hour before you decide.

Want the version of this page for YOUR situation?

Tell me your budget and what your week looks like — I’ll tell you honestly whether St. Johns County fits, and where in it to look first.